|

Silver investors should watch the vaults, not just the price

Silver has slipped below $45 an ounce, yet the big vaults in London and New York have not been filling up, which means the fall is not coming from a surplus of metal, and the supply case for owning silver still stands.

If silver were piling up unsold, the big warehouses would usually show it. They do not. London held less silver at the end of October than a month earlier, the first fall in six months. In New York, the metal ready for delivery against futures barely moved while the price dropped. And India, the world's biggest silver consumer, spent nearly three times as much on silver imports in October as in September. On the stockpiles alone, that is a small positive for silver holders, based on one month of data. It is not a sign of a squeeze, and the next test starts on November 30.

Silver traded near $44.93 an ounce late on November 18. It was down about 5% on the day. Hawkish minutes from the Federal Reserve's last meeting added to bets on a December rate rise. The gold-silver ratio stood near 83, meaning one ounce of gold buys about 83 ounces of silver. Silver is now about 37% below its 2025 close. The latest premium issue at Golden Meadow® found the inventory picture calmer than the price.

London: The first fall in six months

London is the centre of the world's wholesale silver trade, where large bars are stored. At the end of October its vaults held 28,889 tonnes, about 928.8 million ounces (Moz), according to the LBMA's monthly data. That is about 3.1 Moz less than at the end of September, after five monthly rises in a row.

A fall in London's stock is a change in where silver sits, not a measure of silver used up. Some of it may have gone to India, some to exchange-traded funds, which hold silver for investors and trade like shares, and some elsewhere. The LBMA does not say.

The vaults are well stocked but not full. They hold about 21% less than at their June 2021 peak. Metals Focus, a research firm, put the metal available outside those funds at about 267 Moz. Kitco reported the estimate alongside end-September vault data. That is nearly double the 136 Moz of London stock outside funds at the end of September 2025. Metals Focus and the Silver Institute called that a "record (reported) low", and it came weeks before London's October squeeze, when buyers struggled to find metal there. The two figures come from different reports and may not cover exactly the same metal. The 267 Moz figure also predates October's data, so the two cannot be combined to work out a new balance.

Funds may also have drawn on that metal. The iShares Silver Trust, which keeps most of its metal in London, added about 11 Moz from the end of September to November 10. If that metal came out of London's stock, the silver not held by funds fell by more than London's reported total did. That is my inference, because the LBMA does not split its figures by owner.

New York: Steady through the sell-off

COMEX is the main US futures exchange, where traders agree a price today for silver delivered later. Its "registered" silver is metal with a warrant, a receipt that makes it ready for delivery. Registered stock stood at 101.63 Moz on November 9, on the exchange's own report. On November 18 it was about 101.2 Moz, on CME Group figures compiled by MetalCharts. The price fell hard over those nine days, and the deliverable metal hardly changed.

Open interest is the number of futures contracts still open. Counted in ounces, it came to about 5.7 for each registered ounce, the same ratio as a week earlier. Money managers, mostly hedge funds, held net bullish bets of 3,615 contracts on November 10. That is their bets on a rise minus their bets on a fall, and it is close to their lowest since February 2024.

So far fewer of these traders are betting on a rise than earlier in the year. The figure does not show how much forced selling is left, though. Large bets in both directions sit inside that small net number and cancel each other out.

Chart

Sources: LBMA, October and September 2026 vault data | LBMA, June 2021 record | CME Group, COMEX silver stocks, November 9 | MetalCharts, COMEX silver stocks from CME Group data, November 18 | CFTC, COMEX silver open interest and managed money, November 3 and 10 | Kitco, Metals Focus on London and positioning, October 29 | KNN India, citing Reuters, October 23 | India's Ministry of Commerce and Industry, September and October trade data, via Kitco and The Pamphlet | World Silver Survey 2026, Metals Focus and the Silver Institute

The open-interest ratio pairs the CFTC's November 10 figure with registered stock on November 18. The Kitco report carrying the 267 Moz figure does not give its date; it appears beside end-September vault data. The managed-money figures are longs minus shorts in the CFTC's disaggregated report. India's monthly trade release gives values, not tonnes.

India: The buyer came back

India is the world's biggest silver consumer and imports most of what it uses. Dealers told Reuters that in late October the government issued permits to import about 6,500 tonnes over six months. That is about 209 Moz. It comes to roughly nine-tenths of India's imports in all of 2025, which Metals Focus and the Silver Institute put at 232.2 Moz.

A permit is a ceiling, not an order. When the permits were issued, Indian buyers were paying only 45 cents an ounce over official domestic prices. That points to a market that was not short of metal that week.

The first trade figures since then are firmer. India's commerce ministry put October silver imports at $1.91 billion. That is nearly three times September's figure. These are values, not volumes, and the price moved between the two months. October was still about 28% below October 2025, when India was buying heavily during the squeeze in London. November's figures, due in mid-December, will be the first full month under the new permits.

What this means to Silver investors

The stockpiles tell a different story from the price. A price that falls because there is too much silver around tends to leave metal sitting in vaults. In October, London's stock fell and India's imports rose. Into mid-November, New York's deliverable stock held. On one month of data, that is a small positive for the case that the world uses more silver than it produces.

It is not evidence of a shortage you can see yet. London is well stocked, nothing in New York showed strain, and India's buying came after months of curbs. Market reports blame the price fall largely on expectations of a December rate rise and a firmer dollar.

In their interim review on November 12, Metals Focus and the Silver Institute still forecast a sixth annual shortfall in a row, of about 35 Moz. That is smaller than the 46.3 Moz they expected in April. They also said that fund selling and the smaller shortfall have helped ease tightness this year in the physical market, where bars and coins change hands.

The next tests come quickly. November 30 is the first day buyers holding December contracts can be told their metal is ready for delivery. December is one of COMEX's main delivery months. A smooth month with registered stock near 100 Moz would confirm the calm. The LBMA's November figures follow around December 7, and India's November imports in mid-December. Stockpiles are one of the forces I follow in Silver Rising, and I keep track of how silver has traded against them.


Want free follow-ups to the above article and details not available to 99%+ investors? Sign up to our free newsletter today!

Author

Przemyslaw Radomski, CFA

Przemyslaw Radomski, CFA

Gold Price Forecast

Przemyslaw Radomski, CFA (PR) is a precious metals investor and analyst who takes advantage of the emotionality on the markets, and invites you to do the same. His company, Sunshine Profits, publishes analytical software that any

More from Przemyslaw Radomski, CFA
Share:

Editor's Picks

AUD/USD crashes to January lows near 0.6650 after awful Aus jobs data

AUD/USD falls hard to its lowest since January, near 0.6650, in the Asian session on Thursday. The Australian Dollar (AUD) faces intense selling pressure against the US Dollar (USD) following weaker-than-expected Australian employment data, which ramped up RBA interest rate cut bets for next year. The weekly US Initial Jobless Claims report is due later on Thursday.


USD/JPY keeps its range near 159.50 despite hawkish BoJ Ueda

The Dollar rose against most major currencies but not the Yen, which is backed by intervention warnings near 160.00 and hawkish BoJ Ueda's commentary. USD/JPY is keeping its range around 159.50 in Asia on Thursday after a few sessions of small declines from a high just above 160.00. That high was its highest since early September.



Gold hits fresh lows near $3,680

Gold adds to the weekly pullback on Thursday, breaching below the $3,700 mark per troy ounce for the first time since September 2025. The precious metal’s persistent decline follows steady bets for further Fed tightening amid the solid performance of the US Dollar.

Crypto Today: Bitcoin, Ethereum, XRP rise ETF capital outflows

Cryptocurrency prices are gaining momentum on Thursday, albeit gradually. Bitcoin has risen from support near $62,000, edging higher toward $64,000. Altcoins broadly mirror Bitcoin’s gains, with Ethereum holding above $1,800 and Ripple trading slightly higher above $0.98.

Stocks rally in anticipation of $107 billion Anthropic IPO

AI stocks are gaining as strong demand for Anthropic's IPO lifts sentiment after recent selling. Anthropic is set to make history this week as the developer of the Claude artificial intelligence platform begins trading on the NASDAQ exchange under the ticker symbol ANT.

Gold's 14-month low looks mild next to Silver's fall from $121 to $44
Gold has lost a third of its value since January as traders bet on more Federal Reserve rate increases. Silver has lost nearly two-thirds, because the buyers still holding Gold up have no equivalent in the Silver market. Gold is trading below $3,700 for the first time since September 2025, a little more than a third under the record near $5,600 it set in late January.