- Coinbase submitted a comment letter to the US financial regulator asking for clarification on core staking services.
- The exchange explained that staking services fail every single prong of the Howey test, therefore, cannot be treated as securities.
- Coinbase argues that the exchange provided detailed presentations on staking services as early as 2019, leaving ample room for formal guidance.
US-based crypto exchange Coinbase sought clarification regarding the crypto staking services via its letter to the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). The letter dated March 20, 2023, addresses key pain points that many service providers in the crypto industry are facing.
Coinbase urges SEC to provide clear rules on crypto staking
Coinbase asked the SEC to provide rules and guidelines to staking and other complex aspects of the cryptocurrency industry in its recent letter. The exchange noted that.
Staking services are not a monolith. A number of different models exist and while some might be categorized as offering an investment contract, core staking services that we describe in this letter are not."
The poster child for crypto exchanges in the US further argues that staking services do not fit the definition of a securities offering “when applying the analysis laid out in the Supreme Court case, SEC v. W. J. Howey Co. and as refined over the years.”
Additionally, the letter clarifies that,
both the black letter law of the "Howey test" as well as the policy and regulatory concerns underlying that analysis we find that core staking services neither meet the test as a matter of law, nor present the risks the federal securities laws were designed to mitigate.
In its efforts to help the Commission, Coinbase notes its efforts made on December 18, 2019, July 14, 2020, on August 20, 2020, in explaining how these staking services work and why they do not constitute securities. The exchange also notes that there are staking services that are not securities, and there are some that could be viewed as securities.
The US-based exchange adds that there are "no established" processes or regulations that squarely fit the staking services. Hence, Coinbase urges the SEC to provide a "path to workable registration" and encourages the SEC to consider how that "framework should apply to any staking services that do constitute an offering of securities."
The exchange also references its previously submitted petition that deeply implored the "Digital Asset Securities Regulation" topic.
This response from Coinbase comes after the cryptocurrency industry suffered major turmoil, including the collapse of multiple well-established projects and institutions. The contagion from the fall of Terra, 3AC and FTX combined with SEC's crackdown on stablecoin issuers like Paxos or levying fines on Kraken exchange explains this move from Coinbase.
The exchange's executive previously voiced his opinion on SEC's crackdown of staking services.
Coinbase’s letter to the US SEC
In the letter, the exchange explained that there was ample time when it started sharing detailed presentations about staking services in December 2019, before taking the company public in 2021. While the US financial regulator is looked upon for formal guidance and direction in terms of enforcement, there was no clarification in this regard up until February 2023, when the SEC slammed Kraken for sale of unregistered securities, addressing “staking-as-a-service.”
Kraken settled with the SEC for $30 million, but staking is not a security
In February 2023, the SEC hit San Francisco-based cryptocurrency exchange Kraken with a $30 million fine for violating securities laws. The regulatory body announced that the firm had failed to register the offer and sale of their crypto asset “staking-as-a-service” program.
Kraken, one of the leading cryptocurrency exchanges in the ecosystem, settled the SEC’s allegations against it with the payment of $30 million. However, Kraken’s settlement does not imply that “staking constitutes a security.”
As Jake Chervinsky, Chief Policy Officer at Blockchain Association explains, settlements are not the law. While the US SEC thinks that “staking-as-a-service” is a security, Kraken didn’t admit or deny it, instead the exchange chose to settle the matter with a fine.
Settlements are not law. They're a decision that the economics of settling are better than fighting, no more.
— Jake Chervinsky (@jchervinsky) February 9, 2023
The SEC thinks staking-as-a-service is a security. Kraken didn't admit or deny either way.
It may be a tough question, but the SEC hasn't answered it either way today.
Why staking services are not investment contracts
Ari Good, a Blockchain lawyer with clients that include cryptocurrency exchanges and payment companies explains the difference between staking arrangements and investment contracts. Good agrees with Coinbase’s Chief Legal Officer Paul Grewal in that merely serving as an intermediary does not render the underlying economic relationship an “investment contract.”
The US SEC has not entertained the difference between service providers and counterparties in its allegations against Kraken. Serving as a custodian of a fungible asset, especially where such a custodian holds collateral on a 1:1 basis to back every customer account, is a discreet service.
Kraken, Coinbase or any other “staking-as-a-service” providers' rewards do not improve or decline based on the performance of the intermediary. While there should be a clarity on rules and regulations for custodians, the service itself is not a security.
Amidst the ongoing banking crisis and the rise in SEC’s regulation by enforcement cases, Coinbase continues to defend its staking services and seeks clarity from regulators.
Information on these pages contains forward-looking statements that involve risks and uncertainties. Markets and instruments profiled on this page are for informational purposes only and should not in any way come across as a recommendation to buy or sell in these assets. You should do your own thorough research before making any investment decisions. FXStreet does not in any way guarantee that this information is free from mistakes, errors, or material misstatements. It also does not guarantee that this information is of a timely nature. Investing in Open Markets involves a great deal of risk, including the loss of all or a portion of your investment, as well as emotional distress. All risks, losses and costs associated with investing, including total loss of principal, are your responsibility. The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of FXStreet nor its advertisers. The author will not be held responsible for information that is found at the end of links posted on this page.
If not otherwise explicitly mentioned in the body of the article, at the time of writing, the author has no position in any stock mentioned in this article and no business relationship with any company mentioned. The author has not received compensation for writing this article, other than from FXStreet.
FXStreet and the author do not provide personalized recommendations. The author makes no representations as to the accuracy, completeness, or suitability of this information. FXStreet and the author will not be liable for any errors, omissions or any losses, injuries or damages arising from this information and its display or use. Errors and omissions excepted.
The author and FXStreet are not registered investment advisors and nothing in this article is intended to be investment advice.
Recommended Content
Editors’ Picks
US presidential election outcome could shape the future of crypto
US citizens will go to the polls to elect a new president on November 5, and their choice could be key for the future of the crypto industry and thus the price outlook for Bitcoin (BTC).
Bitcoin ETFs beat Gold ETFs with 65% gain since launch
Bitcoin ETFs have reshaped the digital asset investment landscape since their approval in January. Their total assets under management climbed over $70 billion during the weekend, placing them ahead of other investment products, including gold.
XRP eyes 10% rally amid relisting across crypto exchanges and growing institutional demand
Ripple's XRP is trading at $0.5050 up slightly by 0.2% in the past 24 hours as it struggles to sustain a move above a key symmetry triangle resistance. Meanwhile, in its recently released Q3 report, Ripple noted the rising listing and relisting of XRP across crypto exchanges and global platforms.
Ethereum Price Forecast: ETH struggles below $2,500 amid State of Michigan pension fund investment in ETH ETF
Ethereum is trading near $2,420, down about 1% on Monday, but could bounce off a key descending trendline close to the $2,258 historically high demand zone. Meanwhile, the State of Michigan pension fund revealed an investment of $11 million in ETH exchange-traded funds.
Bitcoin: New all-time high at $78,900 looks feasible
Bitcoin price declines over 2% this week, but the bounce from a key technical level on the weekly chart signals chances of hitting a new all-time high in the short term. US spot Bitcoin ETFs posted $596 million in inflows until Thursday despite the increased profit-taking activity.
Best Forex Brokers with Low Spreads
VERIFIED Low spreads are crucial for reducing trading costs. Explore top Forex brokers offering competitive spreads and high leverage. Compare options for EUR/USD, GBP/USD, USD/JPY, and Gold.