We would ignore all of the talk on Wall Street and in the media about whether the stock market is in a bubble. After all, that’s just a matter of semantics, and whatever we call it, the market is overvalued, overbought, and overly bullish at a time when the economy is slogging along at an inadequate pace, and depends almost solely on the prospect of continuing Quantitative Easing (QE) to continue its upward move.
The market doesn’t have to be in a bubble in order for it to be on the precipice of a significant decline. Of all the cyclical market peaks since 1929, only the tops in 2000 and 2007 were looked back on as being bubbles. Most of the other market peaks occurred with the P/E ratio ranging between 18 and 21 times reported cyclically-smoothed GAAP earnings, compared to a norm of 15 times and bear market lows between 7 and 10 times. At today’s market close the P/E ratio is 20.6 times earnings.
That’s high enough to be a potential market top, especially given existing fundamental and technical conditions.
The market has been moving like a yo-yo in response to the minute-to-minute perception of the prospect for Fed tapering.
Yesterday, the market tanked after the release of the Fed minutes indicated that a number of Fed members thought that tapering should begin before a definitive improvement in the economy became apparent. The specific paragraph that got the market’s attention stated, “….participants also considered scenarios under which it might at some stage be appropriate to begin to wind down the program before an unambiguous further improvement in the outlook was underway.” Until this statement, most investors assumed that winding down QE would only take place in a robust economy, and, therefore, would actually be positive. The idea that tapering could begin in the absence of real economic improvement was too much for investors, at least in the short-term.
Today, however, when the Philadelphia Fed Survey released results that were much weaker than expected, the 10-year bond yield abruptly dropped, and stocks soared on the grounds that maybe the start of tapering would be delayed after all. Such is the state of the current market. Everything hinges on QE, and little else seems to matter. The similarity between now and 2000 or 2007 is not necessarily that we are in a bubble, but that the reason for market strength rests on such dubious grounds.
In our view, the market is not supported by strong fundamentals.
The so-called strength in the economy is based on forecasts, rather than on current conditions. But forecasts have now been overly optimistic for the last three years, and we see no change in the period ahead. GDP has been growing at a 1.6% rate over the past year. Similarly, real consumer spending has been rising at a 1.8% rate, and real disposable income at 1.6%----and this with a powerful dose of QE. With the rise in mortgage rates, housing has also become a weak spot. October existing home sales were down 3%, while the pending sales index, which leads existing sales, indicate more declines ahead.
Technical conditions also point to a vulnerable market. Breadth has been narrowing and did not confirm new highs in the averages. Daily new stock highs peaked in May and recently have been trending lower. The Russell 2000 has been lagging the large-cap averages. Some speculative high-P/E momentum stocks have recently been hit hard. Tessler is down 37%, Cree 27%, Fleetmatics 26%, Facebook 15%, and Linkedin 14%.
Investors Intelligence bulls have averaged a historically high 54% and bears 16% over the past four weeks, numbers indicative of market extremes. According to Vanguard, investors, as a group, have a 57% allocation to equities, an amount exceeded only twice in the last 20 years----the late 1990s and prior to 2007-2009. All of these numbers belie the belief that most investors are still too pessimistic.
All in all, we believe that the market is facing significant headwinds, and that a major decline is not far off.
The materials in this website are not an offer to sell or solicitation of an offer to buy any security , nor shall any such security be offered or sold to any person, in any jurisdiction in which such offer, solicitation, purchase, or sale would be unlawful under the securities laws of such jurisdiction. Please call 1-800-GABELLI (1-800-422-3554) or your Advisor for a free prospectus for the Comstock Funds, which contains more complete information on the Funds, including management fees, charges and expenses. Please read it carefully before investing or sending money. © 2002 Comstock Partners, Inc. All rights reserved.
Recommended Content
Editors’ Picks
AUD/USD slides toward 0.6200 after softer Australian inflation data
AUD/USD is flriting with weekly lows, heading toward 0.6200 in Wednesday's Asian trading. Softer-than-expected Australian inflation data reaffirm February RBA rate cut bets, smashing the Aussie. Further, China's economic woes and US-Sino trade war fears weigh further on the pair ahead of the Fed verdict.
USD/JPY trades better bid above 155.50, awaits Fed's decision
USD/JPY picks up fresh bids above 155.50 early Wednesday as traders look to the key FOMC decision before placing fresh directional bets. The divergent Fed-BoJ policy expectations might continue to act as a tailwind for the currency pair, though trade war fears could limit any downside.
Gold price consolidates amid mixed cues; focus remains on Fed
Gold price struggles to capitalize on the previous positive move as investors await the outcome of a two-day FOMC meeting to determine the next leg of a directional move. Meanwhile, Fed rate cut bets and sliding US bond yields might continue to support the non-yielding bullion.
122,000 new investors buying LTC amid Ripple’s latest victory
Litecoin price consolidated above the $110 mark on Tuesday buoyed by positive swings in US regulatory pendulum towards altcoins ETF. On-chain data shows LTC continues to attract new buyers, despite recent volatile market movements.
Australia CPI expected to ease further in December, nearing RBA’s target
Australia will release fresh inflation-related data on Wednesday, and financial markets anticipate price pressures eased further at the end of 2024, paving the way for a Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) interest rate cut when it meets in February.
Trusted Broker Reviews for Smarter Trading
VERIFIED Discover in-depth reviews of reliable brokers. Compare features like spreads, leverage, and platforms. Find the perfect fit for your trading style, from CFDs to Forex pairs like EUR/USD and Gold.